There's an easy answer: Make your own toners!
This recipe has two parts:
1. Make the water-based infusion (tea basically) by selecting from the following list of suggested herbs:
Lavender (Astringent) - Oily skin
Rosemary (Astringent, toning) - Normal to oily skin
Chamomile (Healing) - Normal, Oily, Sensitive, Blotchy skin
Calendula (Healing) - All skin types
Comfrey (Healing) - Dry, Blotchy, Prone to rashes
Elder Flower (Toning) - Normal to Dry skin
Combine with one of the following depending on skin type:
Normal Skin: Apple Cider Vinegar
Oily Skin: Witch Hazel
Very Oily Skin: Vodka
2. Add very hot water. Leave to infuse overnight, if possible. Strain and store in a glass jar, filling up a small bottle weekly.
Quantities
For the water based infusion -2 cups of water to 2 tbs dried herb.
For the final toner, mix the 2 cups (500 ml) of strained infusion with 4 tbs of either apple cider vinegar, witch hazel, or vodka.
Herb choices
Can be mixed and matched. If using a combination, adjust the individual quantities so that the 2 cup to 2 tablespoon ratio is followed.